So many questions fill the world,
So many answers have been heard.
But when the mind clings to a view,
Confusion grows in all we do.
Does it exist? Or does it not?
Some questions tie the mind in knots.
Pause for a moment, look within,
See conditions where they begin.
[Pre-Chorus]
We do not have to judge it all,
We do not have to build a wall.
Whatever arises through a cause,
See it clearly without applause.
[Chorus]
Do not rush to answer, let wisdom lead,
Do not cling to views that strengthen greed.
Some questions fade when we let them go,
Freedom begins when attachment lets go.
Exists or not—do not be bound,
Right or wrong—do not let views surround.
Know the cause, know suffering, know the way,
And let attachment fade away.
[Verse 2]
Khemā Therī, wise and serene,
Spoke of truths beyond what can be seen.
Anurādha learned to understand,
The Tathāgata cannot be held in hand.
Sāriputta and Koṭṭhita too,
Explored what wisdom truly knew.
Not to build another view,
But to see reality as true.
[Bridge]
In a world where information flies,
Where every voice claims to be wise,
Before we judge, before we share,
Pause with mindfulness and care.
[Final Chorus]
Do not rush to answer, let wisdom lead,
Do not cling to views that strengthen greed.
Not every question needs reply,
Some answers only multiply.
Every question can become a way
To see more clearly day by day.
When attachment finally disappears,
The heart finds peace beyond its fears.
[Outro]
Do not rush. Do not cling.
See clearly what conditions bring.
When wisdom shines and views release,
The unbound heart discovers peace.
The Avyakata Saṃyutta: When Wisdom Means Not Rushing to an Answer
The Avyakata Saṃyutta in the Saḷāyatanavagga presents an important Buddhist approach to questions that cannot be usefully answered within fixed categories such as “exists” or “does not exist.” The teachings emphasize freedom from attachment to views and seeing reality according to conditions.
The Avyakata Saṃyutta, found in Volume 18 of the Sutta Piṭaka, Saṃyutta Nikāya, Saḷāyatanavagga, consists of eleven discourses: the Khemā Therī Sutta, Anurādha Sutta, four Sāriputta-Koṭṭhita Suttas, Moggallāna Sutta, Vaccha Sutta, Kutūhalasālā Sutta, Ānanda Sutta, and Sabhiya Sutta.
The opening discourse, the Khemā Therī Sutta, presents the nun Khemā, renowned for her wisdom, in a discussion with King Pasenadi of Kosala. Their discussion leads to questions concerning what happens to the Tathāgata after death—an area in which ordinary categories such as existence and non-existence prove inadequate.
The significance of avyākata, or what is left undeclared, is not simply that the Buddha refused to answer questions. Rather, it points to a deeper principle: wisdom requires knowing which questions are beneficial, which answers are appropriate, and which forms of speculation merely strengthen attachment.
From Seeking Answers to Seeing Reality
The central lesson is to avoid becoming trapped by concepts and fixed philosophical positions.
Questions concerning whether the Tathāgata exists after death, does not exist, both exists and does not exist, or neither exists nor does not exist cannot simply be resolved by imposing ordinary conceptual categories upon a reality that is beyond attachment to a permanent self.
The Buddhist approach therefore places greater emphasis on understanding the aggregates, sense bases, clinging, and the causes of suffering than on constructing metaphysical theories merely to satisfy intellectual curiosity.
The Anurādha Sutta and the series of dialogues involving Sāriputta and Koṭṭhita further explore the problem of defining the Tathāgata and phenomena through rigid categories, pointing instead toward understanding conditionality and freedom from identification.
The remaining discourses continue these themes through conversations involving Moggallāna, Vaccha, Ānanda, and Sabhiya. The collection concludes with the Sabhiya Sutta, the eleventh discourse of the Avyakata Saṃyutta.
A Lesson for the Information Age
In today's information-driven society, the Avyakata Saṃyutta offers a valuable lesson in not rushing to conclusions.
Modern discussions are often reduced to opposing categories: true or false, yes or no, us or them. Such polarization can easily produce attachment, anger, and conflict.
The teaching invites us to pause and ask:
Is there sufficient evidence? Is the answer beneficial? Does holding this view reduce suffering or increase attachment?
Not answering a particular question, therefore, does not necessarily mean ignorance. It can represent the wisdom to recognize when an answer would not lead to liberation from suffering.
The 84000.org Tipiṭaka index identifies the Avyakata Saṃyutta as the tenth Saṃyutta of the Saḷāyatanavagga and lists eleven discourses within it.
The Core Message
The Avyakata Saṃyutta does not teach us to stop asking questions. It teaches us to ask questions wisely.
Some questions may strengthen attachment rather than end suffering. Understanding conditions, abandoning fixed views, and investigating the roots of suffering can lead instead toward wisdom and peace.
Not every question needs an answer, but every question can become an opportunity for wisdom.
[คำแนะนำเพิ่มเติมเกี่ยวกับการใช้งาน: ตามข้อจำกัดของระบบ AI ในปัจจุบัน การสร้างภาพที่มีตัวอักษรภาษาไทยอาจจะยังมีความคลาดเคลื่อนของตัวสะกดหรือรูปสระอยู่บ้าง หวังเป็นพื้นฐานของการศึกษาและจะพัฒนาให้สมบูรณ์ต่อไป]
ไม่มีความคิดเห็น:
แสดงความคิดเห็น